| Wappen | Name | Zeit | |
| 1. |  | Hugues de Payens | 1118–1136 |
| 2. |  | Robert de Craon | 1136–1147 |
| 3. |  | Everard des Barres | 1147–1151 |
| 4. |  | Bernard de Tremelay † | 1151–1153 |
| 5. |  | André de Montbard | 1153–1156 |
| 6. |  | Bertrand de Blanchefort | 1156–1169 |
| 7. |  | Philip of Nablus | 1169–1171 |
| 8. |  | Odo de St Amand (POW) | 1171–1179 |
| 9. |  | Arnold of Torroja | 1181–1184 |
| 10. |  | Gerard de Ridefort † | 1185–1189 |
| 11. |  | Robert de Sablé | 1191–1193 |
| 12. |  | Gilbert Erail | 1193–1200 |
| 13. |  | Phillipe de Plessis | 1201–1208 |
| 14. |  | Guillaume de Chartres | 1209–1219 |
| 15. |  | Pedro de Montaigu | 1218–1232 |
| 16. |  | Armand de Périgord (POW) | 1232–1244 |
| 17. |  | Richard de Bures (Disputed) | 1244/5–1247 [1] |
| 18. |  | Guillaume de Sonnac † | 1247–1250 |
| 19. |  | Renaud de Vichiers | 1250–1256 |
| 20. |  | Thomas Bérard | 1256–1273 |
| 21. |  | Guillaume de Beaujeu † | 1273–1291 |
| 22. |  | Thibaud Gaudin | 1291–1292 |
| 23. |  | Jacques de Molay | 1292–1314 |
